Community: Exchange advice in the forums and read running commentary Resources: Personal running log, calculators, links and other tools for runners News: Running news from around the world Training: Articles and advice about fitness, race training and injury prevention Races/Results: Find upcoming races and past results Home: The Cool Running homepage

Cool Running Races & Tips
Discussion Forums

Got a viewpoint?
Contact us to pitch a viewpoint article for Cool Running

Free e-mail newsletter
Get training news, tips and links free via e-mail.

Free Running Log
Free online running log and tools to keep your training on track. (Partnered with ACTIVETrainer.)
home > community > viewpoint > sub three-hour marathoners at boston: a vanishing breed

Sub Three-Hour Marathoners at Boston: A Vanishing Breed
For many of us there is another right of passage in the marathon: that special achievement of "under three hours."

e-mail E-mail this page
print Printer-friendly page

By Chuck Keating
Posted Thursday, 17 April, 2003

During my racing career, which started in 1968 at the age of 27, the criteria for running a good marathon in the eyes of one's peers was always to break three hours. In 1969 I ran and finished my first Boston in 3:01:43. Although elated to have done so well, my mind kept probing the question: why couldn't I have pushed 104 seconds harder? Only four seconds faster per mile and I could have had a 2:59:59 marathon.

Of course, running a marathon is a satisfying achievement for anyone who completes one, regardless of the final time. Whether it is run in five hours, four hours, or in the elusive three hours or less, finishing the marathon brings great satisfaction. It is the fulfillment of a commitment to train and follow through on a program that allows us to step to the starting line ready to take on the challenge. Finishing the marathon announces to the world that we have met that challenge and conquered the distance.

From non-runners, the most frequently asked question is, "Did you finish?" No more, no less. In their minds that is the crux of the battle. Your final time and the effort (and pain) required to achieve it are incidental. Personal victory is defined in terms of finishing.

And yet, for many of us there is another right of passage in the marathon: that special achievement of "under three hours." I have run eight Boston Marathons. After my 3:01:43 finish in 1969, I came back in 1970 to finish in 2:40:50. The next year, in the 75th running of this great event, I finished in a time of 2:31:25, 31st place overall, good enough to win a medal for being one of the top finishers. It was the pinnacle of my marathon experience. The only personal running success to equal it would come 20 years later, approaching age 52, when I finished Boston in 2:52:21. That was also exciting.

Now in my sixties, with my eighth Boston Marathon last year and my ninth just ahead of me, I will never have that special under three hour achievement again, but I will always take note of all the fine athletes who complete Boston in less than 3:00:00. Surprising to me, however, is that the ranks of sub three-hour finishers have not been growing; it has been shrinking. Here are some numbers that may surprise you.

In 1978, 3,872 runners (mostly men at that time) were recognized in the published results for finishing the Boston Marathon (which in 1978 meant finishing within four hours). Of those finishers, 2,047 broke three hours. In 2002, only 1,024 men broke 3:00 hours. (Of course this was in a significantly larger field. There were 9,234 recognized male finishers, 6,672 of them in under four hours.)

In other words, 24 years later the field of four-hour male finishers had grown by more than 170 percent, but less than 30 percent as many men succeeded in breaking the three-hour barrier. If you look at all of the numbers from the years between 1978 and 2002, you see this has been a steady trend. What does it mean? As more and more people have joined the sport, one can certainly understand why a smaller percentage of finishers would break three hours, but why has the absolute number of sub three-hour finishers dropped? Training methods, shoes, and the winning times have all improved during that time, but not the ranks of finishers sub three-hour finishers. I am inclined to think that we marathoners from the 1970s were a different, tough breed. After all, we were inspired by two of the greats: Frank Shorter with his Olympic Marathon win in 1972, and Bill Rodgers with his outstanding four Boston Marathon victories.

Don Allison, another marathoners from the 1970s, points out that toughness meant training. "People [today] don't do the mileage we used to do. When I started in the mid '70s it was accepted you needed to run a high mileage to do the marathon. You did what others around you did. Nowadays, anyone who runs high mileage is looked at as an aberration." I agree. High mileage to us meant running a minimum of 100 miles a week in training. And if your competition was running 100, you'd try for 105.

Don makes another good point. "Back then we didn't overly concern ourselves with longevity in the sport or absolutely minimizing the risk of injury. Nowadays, many training programs are geared towards recovery and rest days, suggesting the minimum amount of training to get you through the marathon."

In actuality, a well thought-out high-mileage training program will not only prepare you for the marathon, it will significantly increase your chances of attaining a fast time, possibly the elusive sub three-hour finish I hope that soon another generation of American runners will consider the possibilities of LSD for conquering the challenge of the sub 3:00:00 marathon.



Recent Results
Upcoming Events
Post a Race
Submit Results
Online Registration
Sponsored By

Couch-to-5K Google play Couch-to-5K App Store

© 2017 Active Network, LLC and/or its affiliates and licensors. All rights reserved.

About Us | Advertising | Terms of Use| Copyright Policy | Cookie Policy | Security | Your Privacy Rights | Support

Cool Running Facebook Facebook | Cool Running Twitter Twitter | Newsletter Subscription

Race Directors | Running Events | Race Results | Running Tips | Pace Calculator | Couch to 5K | Running Forum | Running News